Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art
Journalist James Nestor investigates how we breathe, and argues that most of us breathe poorly in ways that harm our health, and that simple changes, such as breathing through the nose and more slowly, can help.
Overview
Breath: The New Science of a Lost Art was published in 2020 by James Nestor, a science journalist and a free diver. He had struggled with lung problems and found that breathing exercises helped, which led him to travel and research for years. The book is a mix of his own experiments, interviews with doctors and scientists, and visits to teachers of ancient and modern breathing techniques. His main message is that something as automatic as breathing can be done better, and that the way we do it affects our sleep, stress and well-being.
Full Summary
1. How we lost the habit of breathing well
The idea: Nestor says that many people have grown used to breathing through the mouth, which he blames for a range of problems. He discusses theories that changes in diet and lifestyle, such as softer, processed food, have affected the shape of our jaws and faces, leaving less room in the mouth and nose, and making breathing harder. He presents this as an idea supported by some evidence, but it remains debated.
In real life: A person who often has a stuffy nose may find it natural to breathe through the mouth, without noticing it.
2. A ten-day experiment with the nose
The idea: In one of the bookβs best-known stories, Nestor and another volunteer, the Swedish breathing therapist Anders Olsson, block their noses for ten days, and breathe only through the mouth, while they and a Stanford researcher measure the effects. It is an exploratory experiment on two people, not a clinical trial. He reports that their stress levels rose, their sleep worsened, their blood pressure went up and they snored. After the nose was reopened, many of these changes went away. He uses this to argue that nose breathing is important.
In real life: The nose warms, filters and moistens the air, which a mouth does not do as well.
3. Breathe slowly and exhale fully
The idea: Nestor describes traditions and teachers around the world who have used slow, controlled breathing for health and calm, from ancient yoga to modern coaches. He says that a pace of about five and a half seconds in and five and a half seconds out, which he links to a study of people reciting prayers, is a good rhythm for many people. He suggests that this style may help to calm the nervous system and let the body work with less effort.
In real life: Taking a few slow breaths before a test can steady your nerves.
4. The role of carbon dioxide
The idea: Many people think that more air means better breathing, but Nestor says that carbon dioxide, the gas we breathe out, is also important, since it helps the blood to release oxygen to the tissues. Over-breathing, taking too much air too quickly, can reduce carbon dioxide and make you feel dizzy. He describes a method developed by the Soviet physiologist Konstantin Buteyko that teaches people to tolerate more carbon dioxide and breathe less, and he says that it may help with asthma. These are Nestorβs claims, and a doctor should be consulted about any health condition.
In real life: Holding your breath for a short, comfortable time and then breathing calmly can show how your body reacts.
5. Extreme feats and what they teach
The idea: The book includes stories of people who can control their body with breath, such as free divers who hold their breath for several minutes, and teachers who say that they can withstand cold through breathing and focus. Nestor tries some methods himself, and writes about what he feels. He emphasizes that these are extreme practices, and that most of the benefits come from simple, gentle habits.
In real life: You do not need to dive deep to gain from the idea that calm breathing is a skill.
6. Practical habits
The idea: In the final part, Nestor summarizes ideas that readers can try, such as breathing through the nose during the day and while exercising, breathing slowly for a few minutes, chewing harder, tougher foods and practicing a simple breathing pattern at rest. He says that the changes are small but can be powerful, and that the key is to make them a habit. He also warns that some techniques should not be done in water or when driving.
In real life: Closing your mouth gently when you walk, and noticing your breath, is a way to practice.
Why It Matters
Breath was a bestseller and an introduction to breathing techniques for many readers. It helped to bring ideas from yoga, free diving and sports training to a wider audience, and it prompted many people to try nose breathing and slow breathing for sleep and stress. The book also encouraged researchers to take a new look at an overlooked part of health. It is an example of how a journalist can combine personal experiment and reporting to investigate a topic, and it shows how a basic function can be a field for discovery. Whether or not every claim stands, the book helped to bring the subject of breath into everyday conversation.
Key Takeaways
- Breathing is a skill. It can be improved with attention and practice.
- The nose is made for breathing. It filters, warms and moistens air.
- Slow and gentle is good. Calm breathing may help stress and sleep.
- Carbon dioxide matters. Breathing too much can be as unhelpful as too little.
- Safety first. Some extreme practices are not safe for everyone.
What We Can Learn
You can try a simple experiment: for a few minutes each day, sit quietly and breathe slowly through your nose, making the out-breath a little longer. Notice how you feel. When you are nervous, use a few slow breaths to calm down. Pay attention to whether you breathe through your mouth while you sleep or exercise. If you have asthma, a heart problem or another condition, talk to a doctor before trying new breathing methods, and never practice breath-holding in water or while driving. This is general information, not medical advice.
Criticism and Counterpoints
Some scientists and doctors say that the book makes bold claims on the basis of small studies, or stories, and that important ideas, such as the link between modern diets and facial structure, are not well proven. The ten-day experiment involved only two people, and cannot tell us what would happen for all. Critics also say that some of the claims about the benefits of unusual breathing methods go beyond the evidence. Others praise the book for opening a useful area of inquiry. Readers should treat it as a stimulating introduction and check the claims against medical guidance.
Who Should Read It
This book is for readers who are curious about health, the body and ancient practices, and who like first-person science journalism. It is lively, with some technical parts. People with serious medical conditions should consult professionals, and those who want rigorous clinical evidence may find that more research is needed.
Want the whole book?
A summary is a taste, not the meal. Here is where to find the full book.
You reached the end π
Nicely done. Mark this one as read, and we will suggest what to read next.
Read this next
Born to Run
Christopher McDougall
Christopher McDougall searches for the secret of why running hurts so many people and finds a hidden tribe of Mexican runners, a mysterious ultramarathon legend and a case that humans were made to run for the joy of it.
π HealthThe Blue Zones
Dan Buettner
Dan Buettner visits places around the world where people live unusually long, healthy lives and finds common habits in diet, movement, purpose and community that the rest of us can borrow.
π HealthWhy We Sleep
Matthew Walker
Neuroscientist Matthew Walker argues that sleep is essential for memory, mood, health and long life, and that modern habits are causing a widespread and dangerous lack of it.
π§© Mind & PsychologyHow Not to Die
Michael Greger with Gene Stone
Dr. Michael Greger reviews research on the main causes of early death and argues that a diet based on whole plant foods can prevent and even help to reverse many chronic diseases.
π HealthThe Checklist Manifesto
Atul Gawande
Surgeon Atul Gawande shows that in a world too complex for any expert to remember everything, a simple checklist can prevent mistakes in hospitals, airplanes and building sites.
π HealthOutlive
Peter Attia with Bill Gifford
To live longer and better, we should work early to prevent the chronic diseases that kill most people, by training the body with exercise, paying attention to nutrition and sleep, and caring for our mental health.
π HealthWant something different?
Pick another topic and we will show you three books to start with.

