Chaos: Making a New Science

Ages 13+7 min readmathematicsphysicshistory of science
Get the book ↓

Science writer James Gleick tells the story of a group of scientists who, in the 1960s and 1970s, discovered that simple systems can behave in unpredictable ways, giving birth to chaos theory and a new way of seeing complexity in nature.

Overview

Chaos: Making a New Science was published in 1987 by James Gleick, a science journalist whose early reports on the subject appeared in The New York Times Magazine. It was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and a National Book Award, and introduced the public to chaos theory. The book is a history told through the people who did the work, such as the meteorologist Edward Lorenz, the mathematician Benoit Mandelbrot and the physicists Mitchell Feigenbaum and Doyne Farmer. Gleick describes how they challenged the view that if we know the rules, we can predict the future, and discovered order within disorder.

Full Summary

1. The butterfly effect

The idea: The story begins with Edward Lorenz, a meteorologist at MIT, who in 1961 was running a simple computer model of the weather. To save time, he restarted a run from the middle, typing in numbers from a printout that had been rounded off to fewer decimal places, and the resulting forecast turned out entirely different from the first. He realized that tiny differences in starting conditions can grow into huge differences later, a property known as sensitive dependence on initial conditions. This was later called the butterfly effect, from the idea that a butterfly’s wing flap in one place might influence a storm elsewhere.

In real life: A tiny change in how you start a day can lead to a very different day.

2. The limits of prediction

The idea: Lorenz’s discovery meant that long-term weather prediction is impossible, since we can never measure the atmosphere exactly. More broadly, many systems that follow exact laws, such as the weather, turbulence in fluids and the motion of some bodies in space, are unpredictable in the long run. This was a blow to the dream, associated with Newton and Laplace, that the universe is a clock whose future can be known in principle.

In real life: Weather forecasts are good for a few days, but not for a month.

3. Population, period doubling and the road to chaos

The idea: The author describes how others explored simple equations, such as one for the growth of a population from year to year. For low growth rates, it settles to a steady value; as the rate rises, it starts to oscillate between two values, then four, then eight, and finally behaves erratically, with no repeating pattern. The biologist Robert May explored such equations, and the physicist Mitchell Feigenbaum, working at Los Alamos, found that the splits come faster and faster at a constant rate, which gives a universal number, about 4.669, that turns up in many different equations and suggests a hidden order. The experimenter Albert Libchaber later saw the same doubling of rhythms in a tiny cell of liquid helium, which confirmed that the pattern is not only a mathematical curiosity.

In real life: A pond population can be steady, can cycle, or can swing wildly depending on conditions.

4. Fractals and the geometry of nature

The idea: Benoit Mandelbrot, a mathematician at IBM, noticed that natural shapes such as coastlines, clouds and mountains are rough in a way that looks similar at different scales. His first hint came from records of cotton prices, in which the pattern of daily and monthly changes matched. He coined the term fractal for such shapes, which have a fractional dimension. The length of a coastline, for example, depends on the ruler used. The Mandelbrot set, which he found on a computer screen in 1979, has endless detail yet can be produced by a very short program, and its colorful computer images became a public emblem of chaos.

In real life: A broccoli floret looks like a smaller copy of the whole head.

5. Strange attractors and turbulence

The idea: Gleick discusses how chaotic systems, though unpredictable in detail, tend to follow shapes in the space of their possible states, called strange attractors, such as the double-spiral figure like a pair of butterfly wings that Lorenz found in a simpler three-equation model. These shapes show that chaos has structure. The idea was applied to turbulence in fluids, a problem that had resisted physicists. The mathematicians David Ruelle and Floris Takens proposed that the onset of turbulence needs only a few independent motions, not an endless pile of new rhythms, and experiments by Harry Swinney and Jerry Gollub on water between rotating cylinders showed the flow jumping to a chaotic state, which was a surprise.

In real life: A stream of smoke rises smoothly and then breaks into swirls.

6. A new way of seeing

The idea: The later chapters show how chaos theory spread to other fields, such as biology, in studies of the heart, of epidemics and of ecosystems, while searches for strange attractors in the climate and in stock-market data remained open questions. The pioneers were often outsiders who struggled to be heard: Feigenbaum’s work was turned down by journals for about two years, and Mandelbrot never quite fitted into any single discipline. Gleick argues that chaos changed the way that scientists think about complexity, because it showed that simple rules can produce complex behavior, and that complexity may have simple roots.

In real life: A simple rule, repeated, can produce a complicated pattern, like a snowflake.

Why It Matters

Chaos was one of the first popular books on a new area of science. It helped bring terms such as “butterfly effect” and “fractal” into everyday language, and shaped how the public, and many scientists, think about prediction and complexity. It encouraged interdisciplinary research, and the book is considered a model of science history based on interviews. Its message, that unpredictability does not mean lack of order, has influenced fields from weather forecasting to ecology, and the book is still read as an introduction by students, scientists and anyone who has wondered why the weather, a dripping tap or a crowd can be so hard to predict.

Key Takeaways

  • Small causes can have large effects. The butterfly effect limits long-term prediction.
  • Simple rules can produce complex behavior. Chaos arises in many systems.
  • Chaos has hidden order. Patterns such as strange attractors and universal numbers exist.
  • Nature is fractal. Rough shapes repeat at different scales.
  • New science can begin at the margins. Outsiders often start revolutions.

What We Can Learn

You can use the book to think about the limits of forecasts, and to be humble about predicting complex systems, such as the weather and the economy. Notice the fractal patterns in trees, clouds and rivers on a walk. Try a simple experiment on a calculator, repeating a growth rule such as multiplying a number by a constant and by one minus that number, to see how a tiny change in the starting value can grow. Remember that a small habit can grow into big results, for better or worse. And keep an open mind about ideas that come from unexpected places.

Criticism and Counterpoints

A common criticism is that the book romanticizes the story of a revolution, giving the impression that chaos overturned classical science, when in fact many of the ideas had precursors, such as the work of Henri Poincaré, and that the “heroes” narrative simplifies the contributions of many. Others point out that the practical applications of chaos theory have been more limited than the hype suggested, and that the term is sometimes misused for any kind of disorder. Some reviewers find the book dated. Nevertheless, the main account is considered sound.

Who Should Read It

This book is for readers who are curious about science and mathematics, and who like stories of discovery. It is accessible and lively. Those who want more modern developments, or the technical mathematics, will need other books.

Want the whole book?

A summary is a taste, not the meal. Here is where to find the full book.

You reached the end 🎉

Nicely done. Mark this one as read, and we will suggest what to read next.

Read this next

Fermat's Last Theorem

Simon Singh

Simon Singh tells the story of a simple-looking mathematical puzzle posed by Pierre de Fermat in the seventeenth century, which defeated the best minds for more than three hundred years until Andrew Wiles solved it in the 1990s.

🔬 Science

Gödel, Escher, Bach

Douglas R. Hofstadter

Douglas Hofstadter weaves together the logician Kurt Gödel, the artist M. C. Escher and the composer J. S. Bach to explore how meaning and a sense of self can arise from systems of symbols that refer back to themselves, which he calls strange loops.

🔬 Science

The Signal and the Noise

Nate Silver

Statistician and election forecaster Nate Silver explains why most predictions fail, and shows that better forecasting comes from thinking in probabilities, updating with new evidence and being humble about uncertainty.

🔬 Science

Antifragile

Nassim Nicholas Taleb

Nassim Nicholas Taleb argues that some things, like muscles, immune systems and economies, actually benefit from shocks and stress, and that we should build lives and institutions that gain from disorder, not just resist it.

🧩 Mind & Psychology

The Elegant Universe

Brian Greene

Physicist Brian Greene explains in plain language how string theory tries to unite Einstein's relativity and quantum mechanics by picturing the smallest things in nature as tiny vibrating strings in a universe with extra dimensions.

🔬 Science

A Brief History of Time

Stephen Hawking

One of the world's greatest physicists explains, with almost no math, what we know about the origin, structure and fate of the universe, from the Big Bang to black holes and the nature of time itself.

🔬 Science

Want something different?

Pick another topic and we will show you three books to start with.

Showing books for:
Browse all books →