MIT economists Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee argue that digital technologies such as computers, robots and artificial intelligence are bringing a second machine age, which will bring enormous benefits but also growing inequality, and they say that we must adapt our skills and institutions.
Overview
The Second Machine Age: Work, Progress, and Prosperity in a Time of Brilliant Technologies was published in 2014 by Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee, who both worked at the MIT Sloan School of Management. They compare today’s digital revolution to the Industrial Revolution, which was the first machine age, when steam power extended human muscle. In the second, machines extend the human mind. The authors draw on economics and many examples, such as Google’s self-driving cars and IBM’s Watson, which beat the best human players of the quiz show Jeopardy! The book describes the forces that drive change, and the challenges and policy options, in a sober but optimistic tone.
Full Summary
1. The first and second machine ages
The idea: The authors begin by pointing to a chart of human history in which, for thousands of years, progress was slow, and then, with the steam engine and the Industrial Revolution, it shot upward. This was the first machine age, which overcame the limits of muscle power. They say that we are now in the early stages of a second machine age, in which computers and digital technologies are overcoming the limits of our brains, and the results will be as big as, or bigger than, the first. This is a “hockey stick” change.
In real life: A smartphone now does tasks that once needed many separate devices.
2. Exponential, digital and combinatorial
The idea: Brynjolfsson and McAfee identify three features of the new technologies. They improve exponentially, as in Moore’s Law, in which computing power doubles about every one to two years, so that small changes accumulate into huge ones. They are digital, meaning that they can be copied at almost no cost, with near-perfect fidelity. And they are combinatorial, since each new innovation can be combined with others, creating many new possibilities. These properties make progress fast and widespread.
In real life: A smartphone camera, GPS and maps combine to create ride-hailing apps.
3. Skills machines used to lack
The idea: The authors describe the speed at which machines have mastered tasks that were thought to be uniquely human. Not long ago, experts said that computers could not drive cars in real traffic, but then Google’s self-driving cars logged thousands of miles on American highways, and IBM’s Watson beat the best human Jeopardy! players. They discuss Moravec’s paradox, that high-level reasoning needs little computation, while the skills of a toddler, such as perception and movement, are hard, and that this is being overcome. The pace of progress, they say, is a reason to expect more surprises.
In real life: A phone that understands your spoken question was science fiction a few decades ago.
4. Bounty: the benefits
The idea: The first of the two great effects of the new technology, they say, is bounty: greater abundance, in the form of more and better goods and services, many at low or zero price, such as maps, encyclopedias and free apps. They argue that traditional measures of the economy, such as GDP, miss some of these benefits, since they do not capture free goods. Technology also improves health, education and convenience, and allows people to create and share. This bounty can lift living standards around the world.
In real life: Free online lessons give more people access to knowledge.
5. Spread: inequality and the squeezed middle
The idea: The second effect is spread, a widening difference in income and wealth. The authors show that, while productivity has risen, the median income of workers in the US has stagnated, and a few at the top, such as superstar entrepreneurs, have gained greatly. Technology favors skilled workers over unskilled ones, and capital over labor, and creates winner-take-all markets, where small differences in quality lead to huge differences in reward. Routine jobs, in particular, are at risk from automation.
In real life: A popular app can be used by millions, so that its makers earn far more than the makers of a local alternative.
6. What to do: education, entrepreneurship and policy
The idea: In the last part, the authors offer advice. They urge that we focus on skills that complement machines, such as creativity, interpersonal ability and problem-solving, and not compete with them on routine tasks, and that education be reformed. They support entrepreneurship and a business-friendly environment. They discuss policy ideas, such as improving schools, investing in infrastructure and research, easing immigration of skilled workers, adjusting taxes, for example with taxes on pollution and congestion, and, in the long run, a safety net such as a negative income tax, which they prefer to a basic income. They are optimistic that, with wise choices, we can have a good future.
In real life: A worker who learns to use a new tool may be more valuable than one who ignores it.
Why It Matters
The Second Machine Age was an influential and widely discussed book on the economic effects of technology, was a New York Times bestseller, was shortlisted for the Financial Times Business Book of the Year award, and became a reference in debates about automation and the future of work. It popularized the idea of the “second machine age,” and the contrast between bounty and spread, and its authors helped to shape the conversation among business leaders and policymakers. It reached a wide audience because of its clear writing and its balance between enthusiasm and concern. The book has been followed by other works by the authors, including on artificial intelligence and on the economics of platforms.
Key Takeaways
- We are in a second machine age. Digital technology extends our minds.
- Progress is exponential. Small gains build into huge changes.
- Bounty and spread both occur. Abundance and inequality grow together.
- Complement machines. Focus on creativity and human skills.
- Policy matters. Education, investment and a safety net can shape outcomes.
What We Can Learn
You can use the book to think about how technology affects the kind of work you might do, and about which skills will remain valuable, such as creativity, communication and the ability to learn. Try new tools, and learn how they work. Pay attention to the debates about inequality, and about how benefits of technology are shared. Support education and public investment. And remember that predictions are uncertain, since the future depends on choices, and that technology is not destiny.
Criticism and Counterpoints
Some critics say that the authors are too optimistic about technology’s long-term benefits, and underestimate the speed with which automation could displace workers, or, from the opposite view, that fears of mass unemployment have been wrong in the past. Others point out that the book’s focus is on the US and rich countries, and that it gives limited attention to the global effects and to environmental limits. Some economists disagree about how much of the stagnation of wages is due to technology, as against policies and globalization. One reviewer found the policy ideas reasonable but close to the usual talking points of the technology industry, and others call them modest. A few say that some of its examples are dated. Still, its framework has been widely used.
Who Should Read It
This book is for readers who are interested in technology, work and economics, including students and professionals. It is clear and fairly short. Those who want a deeper treatment of artificial intelligence and jobs may read more recent books.
Want the whole book?
A summary is a taste, not the meal. Here is where to find the full book.
You reached the end 🎉
Nicely done. Mark this one as read, and we will suggest what to read next.
Read this next
The Innovators
Walter Isaacson
Walter Isaacson tells the history of the digital revolution through the people who invented the computer, the internet and the web, and argues that innovation is mostly the product of collaboration, not the work of lone geniuses.
💡 TechnologyAI Superpowers
Kai-Fu Lee
Technology investor Kai-Fu Lee argues that China and the United States will dominate artificial intelligence, explains why China is catching up fast, and warns that AI will transform jobs, calling for a more humane response grounded in compassion and love.
💡 TechnologyLife 3.0
Max Tegmark
Physicist Max Tegmark explores what happens when artificial intelligence matches and then surpasses human intelligence, lays out a range of possible futures, and argues that we should think carefully, now, about which one we want.
🔬 ScienceThe World Is Flat
Thomas L. Friedman
New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman argues that technology and new business practices have leveled the global playing field, so that people anywhere can compete and collaborate with anyone else, and he asks how individuals and countries should respond.
⚖️ Politics & SocietyCo-Intelligence
Ethan Mollick
Wharton professor Ethan Mollick offers a practical guide to working with generative AI as a kind of "co-intelligence," explaining what it does well and badly, and giving four rules for using it effectively and responsibly in work, study and life.
💡 TechnologyThe Shallows
Nicholas Carr
Writer Nicholas Carr argues that the internet is changing the way our brains work, making us better at skimming and multitasking but worse at deep reading, concentration and contemplation.
💡 TechnologyWant something different?
Pick another topic and we will show you three books to start with.
