How Children Succeed
Journalist Paul Tough argues that qualities like perseverance, curiosity and self-control matter more for children's success than test scores alone, and that these qualities can be nurtured, especially for children who face hardship.
Overview
How Children Succeed: Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of Character was published in 2012 by Paul Tough, a journalist who writes about education and poverty. For decades, many people believed that success in school depends mainly on cognitive skills, which are measured by tests. Tough draws on the work of economists, psychologists and doctors to show that “non-cognitive skills” are at least as important. He visits schools, programs and families, and tells stories of children who succeeded or failed. The book looks at what helps children to build character, and how adults can support them.
Full Summary
1. Beyond test scores
The idea: Tough begins with a shift in thinking. Research by the economist James Heckman showed that people who earn a high school equivalency certificate by passing a test do worse in life than regular graduates, even though they scored similarly on tests. The difference seems to lie in persistence, planning and the ability to delay gratification, which a diploma suggests and a test does not. These traits are not measured by IQ, but they matter a great deal for success.
In real life: Two students with the same grades may do very differently in college, if one is better at planning, studying and getting up after a failure.
2. The role of stress in early childhood
The idea: Tough describes research that shows that children who experience a lot of stress and trauma in early life, such as neglect, violence or chaos at home, can develop difficulties with attention and self-control. Their bodies are constantly on alert, and this makes it harder to focus in school. The pediatrician Nadine Burke Harris, who runs a clinic in a poor San Francisco neighborhood, has found that such adverse childhood experiences are linked to children’s health and to how they do in school. The point is that bad behavior in school may have its roots in a hard life.
In real life: A child who is tired and anxious because of problems at home may find it hard to sit still in class.
3. The importance of attachment
The idea: The author says that a secure bond with a caring adult in the first years of life helps children to handle stress and to explore the world. Research he describes, including experiments with rat pups and work on parents and infants, suggests that early experiences shape how children’s bodies and minds respond to stress later. Where such care is missing, later support from teachers, coaches or mentors can make a difference. Tough argues that building character depends on relationships, and not just on discipline.
In real life: A teacher who believes in a struggling student may change that student’s future.
4. Grit and character strengths
The idea: Tough introduces research on grit, the combination of perseverance and passion for long-term goals, by the psychologist Angela Duckworth. He also describes schools that have tried to teach character strengths, such as zest, gratitude and curiosity. Two educators, Dave Levin of the KIPP charter schools and Dominic Randolph of the private Riverdale Country School, decide to make character part of the curriculum. At KIPP, the students who stayed in college were not always the top academic performers, but they were often the more resilient and optimistic ones, and KIPP began to give a character report card alongside regular grades. At Riverdale, the school head worried that wealthy students were shielded from failure. Here, character means habits and skills that can be developed with support, not a measure of moral worth.
In real life: A student who keeps practicing a hard piece of music, in spite of mistakes, is showing grit.
5. The chess team story
The idea: In one memorable chapter, Tough tells of I.S. 318, a middle school in Brooklyn, New York, that has a remarkable chess team, led by a dedicated teacher, Elizabeth Spiegel. The students, many of them from poor families, do very well in national tournaments. The teacher teaches them to analyze their losses, to think carefully and to accept that failure is a path to improvement. The story shows that high expectations, practice and honest feedback can help children to flourish, whatever their background.
In real life: Reviewing your mistakes after a game, without shame, makes you a better player.
6. What adults can do
The idea: The final part considers what parents and teachers can do. Tough argues that, instead of shielding children from all failure, adults should help them to learn to cope with difficulty, and that this is especially true for children of privilege, who may lack the experience of failure. For poor children, he points to the need to reduce the chronic stress they face and to give them strong, supportive relationships. He emphasizes that character is not a fixed trait, but something that can be developed.
In real life: A child who has never failed may be more afraid of it than one who has learned to recover.
Why It Matters
How Children Succeed was a bestseller and entered the national conversation on education. It helped to shift attention from test scores alone toward character and emotional skills, and influenced schools, funders and policymakers, many of whom began to include social and emotional learning in their programs. The book brought together research from several fields and presented it in an engaging way. It also highlighted the effects of poverty and stress on children, and argued that supportive relationships are key to success. While the debate on how best to teach character continues, the book raised important questions.
Key Takeaways
- Character matters. Perseverance and self-control influence success.
- Stress affects learning. Early hardship can impair attention and behavior.
- Relationships build resilience. Supportive adults make a difference.
- Failure can teach. Children need chances to struggle and recover.
- Character can grow. These skills can be nurtured at any age.
What We Can Learn
Think about the habits that help you to keep going when something is hard, such as breaking a task into steps, asking for help and reviewing mistakes. If you work with children, try to be a steady, caring presence, and give them a chance to try again after failing. Be gentle with behavior that may have a hidden cause. Look for ways to help children in your community to have the support that they need. And remember that you can develop your own grit, with practice and encouragement.
Criticism and Counterpoints
Some critics say that the book overstates the case for character traits and that grit and similar traits are difficult to measure or to teach, and that schools should not use them for grading or for accountability. Researchers, including Duckworth, have warned against such uses. Others argue that the focus on individual character can distract from structural problems such as poverty and inequality, and that it may blame children for situations they did not create. One reviewer notes that the book defines success narrowly, as school performance and college attendance, and gives little practical guidance on how to teach these qualities. Tough himself admits that some of them, such as motivation, are hard to explain.
Who Should Read It
This book is for parents, teachers, policymakers and anyone interested in why some children succeed. It is readable, with stories as well as research. Those who want detailed studies of the science of character will need to consult the original research.
Want the whole book?
A summary is a taste, not the meal. Here is where to find the full book.
You reached the end 🎉
Nicely done. Mark this one as read, and we will suggest what to read next.
Read this next
Grit
Angela Duckworth
Psychologist Angela Duckworth argues that success depends not only on talent but on grit, a combination of passion and long-term perseverance, and shows how people can grow it in themselves and others.
🌱 Self-ImprovementMindset: The New Psychology of Success
Carol S. Dweck
Psychologist Carol Dweck shows that people who believe abilities can grow, a growth mindset, learn, cope with failure and achieve more than people who believe their talents are fixed.
🌱 Self-ImprovementHow to Raise an Adult
Julie Lythcott-Haims
A former dean at Stanford University argues that modern parents who do too much for their children, from homework to college applications, are leaving them anxious and unprepared, and she urges them to step back and let young people learn to stand on their own.
🎓 Parenting & EducationPositive Discipline
Jane Nelsen
Jane Nelsen argues that children behave better when they are treated with both kindness and firmness, and she offers practical tools, such as family meetings and logical consequences, to teach them responsibility without punishment or pampering.
🎓 Parenting & EducationCreative Schools
Ken Robinson and Lou Aronica
Sir Ken Robinson and Lou Aronica argue that schools are held back by a factory-style model of standardized testing, and call for an approach built on personalization, creativity and the real interests of students and teachers.
🎓 Parenting & EducationHow to Talk So Kids Will Listen and Listen So Kids Will Talk
Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish
Parents can get better cooperation and closer relationships by acknowledging children's feelings, describing problems instead of blaming, and using simple, respectful communication skills.
🎓 Parenting & EducationWant something different?
Pick another topic and we will show you three books to start with.






