Maybe You Should Talk to Someone

Ages 16+8 min readmemoirpsychotherapymental health
Content notes a patient's terminal cancer and death; the death of a patient's young son; grief; miscarriage; divorce; addiction and drunk driving; some strong language; brief sexual references; discussion of suicidal thoughts in one patient's story
Get the book ↓

Psychotherapist Lori Gottlieb, after her own sudden breakup, becomes a patient herself, and weaves her story with those of her clients to show that everyone needs help understanding their lives, and that change is possible.

Overview

Maybe You Should Talk to Someone: A Therapist, HER Therapist, and Our Lives Revealed was published in 2019 by Lori Gottlieb, a psychotherapist who also writes the Dear Therapist advice column for The Atlantic and who earlier worked in television. The book is told in 58 short chapters and follows five main threads: her own therapy, after her boyfriend suddenly leaves her, and the stories of four of her patients, a television producer, a young woman with a terminal illness, an older woman who says she will end her life on her birthday if nothing gets better, and a woman in her twenties whose drinking and choice of partners keep hurting her. The patients’ details are changed to protect their privacy. The tone is warm, funny and honest.

Full Summary

1. The therapist who needs a therapist

The idea: Gottlieb opens with the shock of a breakup. Her boyfriend leaves, saying that he cannot have a child living in his home for another decade, after a relationship that had seemed to be heading toward a shared future. She is devastated, and finds that she cannot rely on her own professional skills to cope. A friend urges her to see someone, a colleague refers her to a therapist named Wendell, and, to her surprise, she finds herself in the position of the patient. In their first session she hopes that he will agree that her ex is to blame, but Wendell instead suggests that she may be grieving something beyond the relationship, which catches her off guard. Over the rest of the book she deals with a mystery health problem that doctors cannot pin down, and with a book contract for a happiness book that she cannot bring herself to write and eventually cancels. Along the way she looks back at her earlier life, which included work in television, a period in medical school that she left, becoming a single mother by choice and then training as a therapist. She shows that therapists have problems, and that being a human being is the common condition.

In real life: Even a person who gives advice for a living may need help of their own.

2. John, the angry television producer

The idea: One of Gottlieb’s patients is John, a successful Hollywood television producer, who is married with children. He is arrogant and angry, and comes to therapy believing that everyone around him is an idiot and that they are the problem. He is not an easy patient: he dominates the conversation, insults people, and at first keeps checking his phone during sessions until she asks him to put it away. Gottlieb sees that his behavior is pushing people away, including his wife, Margo, and that he is hiding pain. He walks out of treatment at one point, and then returns. She later learns that he has suffered a terrible loss, the death of his young son Gabe, which he has barely been able to talk about. She encourages him to allow himself the full range of his feelings, rather than hold them in, and as he begins to grieve openly he is able to share more of it with Margo. The book also reveals that Margo is a patient of Wendell’s.

In real life: Someone who blames everyone else may be hiding hurt that they cannot face.

3. Julie, living with a deadline

The idea: Julie is a newly married university professor in her thirties. Soon after her wedding she is treated for cancer, and she also loses a pregnancy. She hopes that the illness is behind her, but later she learns that she has a rare and incurable form of the disease, and she asks Gottlieb to help her face her death. The book follows her as she struggles with her situation and with the often clumsy reactions of the people around her, including a friend who shares an essay about an unexpected change of plans. She dreams of working as a cashier at a grocery store, and then does it. With her husband, Matt, she plans her own funeral with dark humor, and Gottlieb stays with her to the end of her life. Caring for her reminds the therapist of how fragile life is.

In real life: Facing a limited time can make people clear about what matters.

4. Rita and the plan to end it all

The idea: Rita is an older woman, about to turn seventy, who says that she will take her own life on her birthday if her life does not get better. She has been divorced more than once, she is lonely, her adult children do not speak to her, and she is full of regrets. Gottlieb takes this seriously and tries to find out what is under the plan. Rita turns down many of her suggestions, but over time Gottlieb discovers a history of pain, including guilt about not shielding her children from their father, and a longing for connection. Rita starts sharing her art online, teaches neighborhood children, and grows close to an old friend, Myron, whose kiss both thrills and frightens her. She also writes to him about her past, and begins to hear from her children. The story is handled with care, and shows how patience and attention can offer a person a reason to stay.

In real life: A person who says that they want to give up may be crying out for connection.

5. What happens in a therapy room

The idea: Gottlieb describes the practice of therapy, with its mix of listening, challenge and humor, and the many ways that people avoid change. One more patient, Charlotte, is a woman of twenty-five who is anxious and bored at work, drinks every night, and keeps falling for partners who are not available, even flirting with another patient she sees in the waiting room. After a drunk-driving incident Charlotte begins to face her drinking, seeks treatment, and at one point tries to leave therapy before choosing to stay. Gottlieb draws on ideas from psychology, such as the stages of change, the pull to repeat old patterns, the existential concerns of death, isolation, freedom and meaninglessness, and the difference between counseling and therapy. The book shows therapy as a place where people learn to see themselves more clearly, rather than a place where they are simply told what to do.

In real life: Talking through a problem with an attentive listener can show you what you could not see.

6. Change, compassion and everyone’s story

The idea: In the end, the stories converge on a common theme: that we are all more alike than different, and that people can change when they feel understood. Gottlieb’s own breakup leads to growth, and a better understanding of what she wants. She regains her energy for writing and, after a long stretch of work with Wendell, treats the end of their sessions as a pause in a conversation rather than a final goodbye. The title itself is a gentle suggestion that talking to someone about our problems can help. The book ends on a note of hope.

In real life: Saying out loud what troubles you can be the beginning of feeling better.

Why It Matters

Maybe You Should Talk to Someone was a New York Times bestseller and was praised for demystifying therapy, by showing it from both sides of the couch, and by showing that a therapist is a person too. It was praised for its humor, honesty and compassion, and it has helped many readers to understand what therapy can look like. It is also a story of the human need for connection and understanding, and of resilience. A television adaptation was in development, and Gottlieb’s TED talk was among the most watched of 2019. She has continued to write and speak about mental health.

Key Takeaways

  • Everyone needs support. Even professionals have struggles.
  • Behavior has hidden reasons. Anger and avoidance often cover pain.
  • Change is possible. Understanding yourself can free you.
  • Connection heals. Being heard makes a difference.
  • Therapy is not weakness. Seeking help is a way to understand yourself and to grow.

What We Can Learn

You can use the book to think about whether you are carrying something that would be easier to bear if shared. Practice listening to others without rushing to give advice, and ask yourself what story you tell about your own life. If you are going through a hard time, speak to a trusted person, a counselor or a doctor, and know that asking for help is a sign of strength. If you are worried about your safety, contact a crisis line or emergency services immediately. Remember that therapy comes in many forms, and finding a good fit takes time.

Criticism and Counterpoints

A reviewer in The New York Times noted that Gottlieb can be judgmental and obsessive, though also authentic, even raw, about herself and her patients. Because the book tells a handful of vivid stories with a satisfying arc, readers should remember that it may present a more polished version of therapy than most people experience, and that the patients’ details are changed for privacy, so the stories are best read as illustrations. Therapy is also not accessible to everyone, because of cost and availability, and the book does not focus on that problem. Most readers find it moving.

Who Should Read It

This book is for adult readers who like memoirs, and who are curious about therapy or want to understand themselves and others better. It includes difficult themes such as illness, the death of a child, suicide and addiction, and some strong language. Those in crisis should seek immediate help from a professional.

Want the whole book?

A summary is a taste, not the meal. Here is where to find the full book.

You reached the end 🎉

Nicely done. Mark this one as read, and we will suggest what to read next.

Read this next

Reasons to Stay Alive

Matt Haig

Novelist Matt Haig describes how he lived through severe depression and anxiety, how he found his way back, and why he believes that hope is always possible, even when it feels out of reach.

🍎 Health

The Year of Magical Thinking

Joan Didion

Joan Didion writes with precision and restraint about the year after her husband's sudden death, when she also faced her daughter's grave illness, and she examines how grief can warp thinking and time.

👤 Real Lives

When Things Fall Apart

Pema Chodron

Buddhist nun Pema Chodron teaches that when life falls apart, the way forward is not to run from pain or to fix everything, but to stay with the uncertainty, to soften and to meet our fear and sorrow with kindness.

🕊️ Philosophy & Religion

The Body Keeps the Score

Bessel van der Kolk

Psychiatrist Bessel van der Kolk argues that trauma leaves lasting marks on the brain and body, and that healing needs more than talking: it involves restoring a sense of safety, body awareness and connection.

🧩 Mind & Psychology

Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy

David D. Burns

Psychiatrist David Burns introduces cognitive therapy to a general audience, teaching that depression and anxiety are driven by distorted thoughts, and showing readers how to identify and challenge them in order to feel better.

🧩 Mind & Psychology

Thinking, Fast and Slow

Daniel Kahneman

Our minds run on two systems, a fast, intuitive one and a slow, careful one, and understanding how the fast system fools us can help us make better decisions about money, risk, work and happiness.

🧩 Mind & Psychology

Want something different?

Pick another topic and we will show you three books to start with.

Showing books for:
Browse all books →