The Little Book of Common Sense Investing

Ages 13+10 min readinvestingpersonal finance
Get the book ↓

John Bogle, founder of the investment firm Vanguard, argues that most people should buy and hold a low-cost fund that owns the whole stock market, because costs quietly eat up the gains from active investing.

Overview

The Little Book of Common Sense Investing was published in 2007 by John C. Bogle, who founded Vanguard in 1974 and, as he tells it, created the world’s first index mutual fund the following year. The book is short and written for non-experts. Its central claim is that the stock market, as a whole, gives a good return, but that investors in it, as a group, earn less than the market because of fees, trading costs and taxes, and that fund investors tend to do even worse because of poorly timed and poorly chosen purchases. The answer is to own the market at a very low cost and to hold on for a long time. Bogle backs this up with plain arithmetic.

Full Summary

1. Own the whole market

The idea: An index fund buys the stocks in a market index and simply holds them. The classic version Bogle champions owns essentially the entire U.S. stock market, weighted by company size, with minimal expenses and almost no trading. Because it owns everything, it earns the market’s return less only a tiny cost. He opens with a parable, his version of a story from Warren Buffett, about the Gotrocks family, who own every stock in the country and grow wealthier together. Then a few Helpers (brokers, then money managers, then consultants) persuade some cousins that they can do better than the rest. Each Helper takes a fee, the trading creates extra taxes, and the family’s share of the pie shrinks, until a wise old uncle tells them to dismiss everyone and go back to holding it all. That, Bogle says, is exactly what an index fund does. He admits that index funds are dull in the short run, but argues that they make up for it over the long run, and that they remove the risk of picking the wrong stocks, sectors or managers, leaving only the risk of the market itself.

In real life: Instead of betting on which single horse will win a race, you own a little of every horse, and share in the whole event.

2. The arithmetic of costs

The idea: Bogle’s key argument is simple, and he calls it the relentless rules of humble arithmetic. Before costs, all investors together earn exactly the market’s return, so beating the market is a zero-sum game: for every winner there is a loser. After costs (commissions, management fees, sales charges and the like), investors as a group must fall short of the market by the total of those costs, so beating the market becomes a loser’s game. He estimates that the all-in cost of owning an equity mutual fund, including hidden trading costs, can reach about 3 to 3.5 percent a year. Over the 25 years from 1980 to 2005, he reports, the S&P 500 returned about 12.5 percent a year and the average equity fund about 10.0 percent, while an S&P 500 index fund returned about 12.3 percent. A $10,000 investment in the index fund grew by about $170,800, against about $98,200 in the average fund.

In real life: If two runners have the same speed, but one carries a heavy bag, the one without the bag will finish first.

3. The power of compounding, and the weight of costs

The idea: Over many years, small differences in costs add up to a huge amount. Compounding means that returns earn further returns, so money grows faster over time. Bogle says that costs compound too, and he calls this the tyranny of compounding costs. His example assumes that stocks return 8 percent a year for 50 years and that the average fund’s costs of 2.5 points a year leave its investors 5.5 percent. A $10,000 stake grows to about $469,000 in the market but only about $145,400 in the average fund, so costs consume nearly 70 percent of the potential gain. Compounding also works in business’s favor: he notes that a dollar invested in 1900 at the 9.5 percent return earned by American businesses would have grown to roughly $15,000 by the end of 2005 (about $793 after adjusting for inflation).

In real life: A small leak in a bucket may not matter in a minute, but over a day, the bucket is empty.

4. Investing versus speculating

The idea: Following the economist Keynes, Bogle splits stock returns into two parts. Investment return is what businesses produce: the starting dividend yield plus earnings growth. Speculative return is the effect of changing price/earnings multiples, which swing with investors’ greed, hope and fear. Since 1900 the market’s return averaged about 9.6 percent a year, almost the same as the 9.5 percent investment return (roughly 4.5 points from dividends and 5 from earnings growth), so speculation added only about 0.1 point. In the long run, he says, business reality rules, and the stock market is a giant distraction. He cites an academic study of the most active fifth of traders, who turned their portfolios over at more than 21 percent a month between 1990 and 1996: they earned the market’s 17.9 percent a year but lost about 6.5 points of it to trading costs. He also warns that the 12.5 percent market return of 1980 to 2005 included nearly 3 points of speculation, and he expected more modest returns ahead (his own guess was about 7 percent a year for stocks over the next decade).

In real life: Buying a house to live in for decades is a different act from buying a house in hope that the price will jump next month.

5. Why active funds usually fall short

The idea: Bogle asks why so many funds fail to beat the market. Managers charge high fees, their funds turn over their portfolios about 100 percent a year, and taxes on the resulting gains reduce results: he estimates that taxes cost the average fund’s taxable investors about 1.8 points a year. Picking winners in advance is very hard. Of 355 equity funds in existence in 1970, 223 had vanished by 2005, and only 24 beat the S&P 500 by more than a point a year; just three combined survival with a lasting record of excellence. Strong results also tend to fade, a pattern he calls reversion to the mean. The top 20 funds of each year from 1982 to 1992 ranked only 284th on average the following year, out of 681 funds, barely above the middle. The top ten funds of the 1997 to 1999 bubble all fell into the bottom 60 of 851 funds soon after. Investors who chase last period’s winners are punished: he estimates that from 1980 to 2005 the average fund investor earned only about 7.3 percent a year, below the 10.0 percent the average fund reported, because money flowed in after good years and out after bad ones. His advice is to stop hunting for the needle in the haystack and simply buy the haystack.

In real life: A student who changes study methods after every test, and chases whichever friend scored highest last time, may never settle on a good plan.

6. Keep it simple, and stay the course

The idea: The practical advice is to start investing early and put money away regularly, to buy a broad, low-cost index fund, and to hold on during drops. Costs matter even among index funds: in his example, two S&P 500 index funds that began in the 1970s and 1980s turned $10,000 into a profit of $122,700 for the cheap one and $99,100 for the one with a sales charge and higher fees. The same logic applies to bond funds, and he is wary of trendy new index strategies and of trading exchange traded funds. He suggests holding a mix of stocks and bonds that fits your age, with a rule of thumb that the share in bonds roughly equals your age (or perhaps your age minus ten), while admitting that there are no hard rules and that many experts think his guideline too cautious. For readers who crave excitement, he allows a small Funny Money account of no more than 5 percent of their investments, with the rest in a Serious Money account that is at least half, and ideally all, in index funds. He stresses that expenses and emotions, such as greed and fear, are the two great enemies of the investor, and he advises ignoring the noise of the market and keeping a steady, simple plan.

In real life: A person who plants a tree and waters it for years does not dig it up every week to check the roots.

Why It Matters

Bogle is widely admired for bringing low-cost investing to millions of people. In the book he recalls that in the early years of indexing his voice was a lonely one, but by 2007 he reports that some $5 trillion was invested in index strategies. This book is the short and friendly form of his ideas for first-time investors, and it explains why fees matter and why the market is hard to beat. At the end of each chapter he gathers supporting words from well-known investors, academics and journalists, including Warren Buffett and the economist Paul Samuelson, to whom the book is dedicated. His voice is clear and his argument rests on arithmetic, which anyone can check. For people who are starting to save, it is one of the best-known guides to a simple and sound approach.

Key Takeaways

  • Costs are the enemy. Fees and trading costs reduce your share of the market’s return.
  • Own the market. A broad index fund spreads risk and avoids the need to pick winners.
  • Time is your ally. Compounding rewards patience and early saving.
  • Do not chase performance. Last year’s best fund is rarely next year’s.
  • Stay the course. Expenses and emotions are the two great enemies of the investor.

What We Can Learn

If you have savings or plan to save, check the fees on any fund or account, and compare them. A tiny percentage can matter a great deal over decades. Think about investing as a long journey, not a quick race, and avoid decisions made in fear or excitement. Even a young person with a small income can benefit from the habit of saving regularly and keeping it simple. And when you hear about a hot tip, ask who earns money from it, and whether it beats a plain, cheap alternative. Remember that this is general education, and that you should check your own situation before you invest.

Criticism and Counterpoints

Some critics say that if everyone invested only in index funds, there would be nobody to set prices through research, and that markets could become less efficient or more fragile. Others point to active managers who have outperformed for long periods, even if few do; Bogle himself admits that a handful of funds have done so. The advice to hold stocks through downturns can also be very hard to follow, especially for people who need their money soon. Bogle founded Vanguard, which benefits from the popularity of index funds, though he admits this openly and says the book does not enrich him, and his tone can be insistent. The book also focuses mostly on the United States market, with only a modest share of foreign stocks suggested for most readers.

Who Should Read It

This book is for beginners and for anyone who wants a short, clear explanation of why many experts recommend index funds. It is written in mostly plain language, and it can be read in an evening. Readers who enjoy picking stocks may find it too one-sided, and those who need advice about taxes or about a particular country’s rules will need other sources.

Want the whole book?

A summary is a taste, not the meal. Here is where to find the full book.

You reached the end 🎉

Nicely done. Mark this one as read, and we will suggest what to read next.

Read this next

A Random Walk Down Wall Street

Burton G. Malkiel

Burton Malkiel argues that stock prices are so hard to predict that most investors, professional or not, are better off holding a broad, low-cost index fund than trying to beat the market.

💰 Money & Economics

The Simple Path to Wealth

J. L. Collins

J. L. Collins explains, in the form of letters to his daughter, how to build wealth with a simple plan: avoid debt, spend less than you earn, and invest steadily in a low-cost fund that owns the whole stock market.

💰 Money & Economics

The Intelligent Investor

Benjamin Graham

Successful investing is less about being clever than about being disciplined: buy sound businesses at a price that leaves a margin of safety, and don't let the mood of the market push you around.

💰 Money & Economics

One Up on Wall Street

Peter Lynch with John Rothchild

Peter Lynch, a famous mutual fund manager, argues that ordinary people can beat professional investors by buying shares in businesses they understand from daily life, and he explains how to research and judge them.

💰 Money & Economics

The Psychology of Money

Morgan Housel

How you behave with money matters more than how much you know about it, and good financial outcomes come from humility, patience and avoiding big mistakes, not from being the smartest person in the room.

💰 Money & Economics

The Wealth of Nations

Adam Smith

A nation's true wealth is not its stock of gold but the goods and services its people produce, and that wealth grows fastest when people specialize, trade freely and compete, with government providing justice, defense and public goods.

💰 Money & Economics

Want something different?

Pick another topic and we will show you three books to start with.

Showing books for:
Browse all books →